In the heart of Deptford, Marcella has quietly built a reputation for doing the simple things exceptionally well. For eight years, this humble neighbourhood Italian has served dishes that everyone at the table wants to try, where every ingredient earns its place on the plate. Front of house manager Katy Annand, who joined in 2019, puts it best: “It’s genuinely such a lovely place to work and I feel like everyone who works here cares about what they do and they love to provide an enjoyable evening for people. It’s about the experience as well as the food. There is a high level of care and thought with the food and drink.”

The evening begins with a bowl of pickled vegetables, an elegant nod to Italian antipasti. The quick brine, a blend of water, vinegar, salt, and sugar, is rounded out with a drizzle of olive oil, giving the vegetables a subtle softness, but enough bite to work up your appetite. Alongside, plump, salty Manzanilla olives, that no doubt make their rounds to the guests packed at each table. Aperitivo’s seem to flow on tap here as Aperol Spritz’s (done correctly with plenty of Prosecco and no soda water) and butter yellow Limoncello spritzers are toasted with new friends at the table.
The cocktails just about hit empty in our glasses when bottles of wine land on our table by our hosts, perfectly timed with the start of our first course. Tule Catarratto, a Terre Siciliane IGP is a crisp white from Sicily. Its delicate notes of citrus blossom offer a gentle acidity that has the ability to carry through to the end of our meal. This refreshing medium bodied wine also had notes of green apple and white peach which would later serve us well.
Our first course set the tone for Marcella’s skill in balancing flavour and texture. Poached veal arrived under a blanket of silky tuna sauce, an iconic combination from northern Italy’s culinary tradition. The meat was meltingly tender (so I was told, as I am pescatarian). Judging from the immediate silence at the table, it could be assumed it had gone down well. The sauce was rich yet clean, lifted by a scattering of sweet, ripe tomato slices.

A salad followed that was anything but ordinary. Generous strands of creamy stracciatella tumbled with tangy lettuce, toasted hazelnuts and sharp black olives. The interplay of flavours was beautifully executed. The creaminess of the cheese, the bitterness of the greens, the earthy crunch of the toasted hazelnuts, and the saline bite of the olives created a dish that lingered long in the memory of the evening.

The main course demonstrated the kitchen’s ability to let the produce shine, which is something I long for during dinners out. A fillet of sea bass, its skin neatly scored, was roasted with garlic and rosemary until the flesh flaked under the fork. Lemon brought a bright acidity, cutting through the soft flavour of the fish. Served with a generous side plate of dressed baby gem lettuce – mint, capers and lashings of olive oil making for a cool, briny counterpoint. This was serenaded by another large plate of roasted vegetables. A spinach purée, smooth and a vivid green anchored the plate, while soft, tangy cooked yellow beetroot offered a gentle sweetness. Long courgettes, blistered plum tomatoes and perfectly crispy roast potatoes were fought over as forks from across the table took their chance on this harvest-like plate of produce.
We paused, drank and made time to chat. Dessert arrived with wide eyes and mouths watering once again. Halves of nectarine had been grilled, coaxing out their natural sugars while adding a prominent savoury smoke. These halves were paired with a peach caramel and a cloud of mascarpone. A salty crumb scattered over the top cut through the sweetness and brought the whole dish into balance. The Catarratto’s mellow stone-fruit notes mirrored the nectarines, tying the meal together in a quiet, elegant full circle sip.
For Katy, part of Marcella’s magic lies in its adaptability, “The joy of the menu is that you can do it however you want – a sharing version with loads of little bits of everything, or you can go, ‘I want a Cacio e pepe, a bowl of pasta and a glass of wine.’ Whatever way you do it, you’re going to get delicious food with nice considerate service.” And if there’s one dish that deserves a place in the restaurant’s hall of fame, it’s the olive oil cake. Katy gushes, “It’s a lemony, orangey, somehow dense but really light bite. It’s a fan favourite with a cult-like following.”
Eight years in, Marcella is not resting on its laurels. It remains a place of caring service, quality ingredients and a desire to please everyone, one bite at a time.
For groups of eight or more, Marcella offers a £40 per person menu featuring four courses – a generous mix of starters, pasta, mains, and dessert.
165A Deptford High St, London SE8 3NU


